Debates in the Senate on the Seventeenth Amendment, 1911

May 8, 1911 (2)

ELECTION OF SENATORS BY DIRECT VOTE.3 min read
1: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 1 (Senate1911.May8b.1)

Mr. BORAH. I move that the Senate proceed to the consideration of the joint resolution (H. J. Res. 39) proposing an amendment to the Constitution providing that Senators shall be elected by the people of the several States.

2: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 2 (Senate1911.May8b.2)

The VICE PRESIDENT. The question is on agreeing to the motion of the Senator from Idaho.

3: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 3 (Senate1911.May8b.3)

Mr. HEYBURN. On that I ask for the yeas and nays.

4: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 4 (Senate1911.May8b.4)

The yeas and nays were ordered, and the Secretary proceeded to call the roll.

5: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 5 (Senate1911.May8b.5)

Mr. BACON (when his name was called). I am paired with the Senator from Maine [Mr. FRYE]. I transfer the pair to my colleague [l\Ir. TERRELL] and vote "yea."

6: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 6 (Senate1911.May8b.6)

Mr. JOHNSTON of Alabama (when Mr. BANKHEA.D's name withdraws his request? was called). My colleague [Mr. BANKHEAD] is absent and is paired with the Senator from Wisconsin [Mr. STEPHENSON]. If my colleague were present, he would vote " yea."

7: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 7 (Senate1911.May8b.7)

Mr. DILLINGHAM (when . his name was called). I transfer my pair with the senior Senator from South Carolina [Mr. TILLMAN] to the Senator from Massachusetts [l\Ir. LoDGE], and I vote " yea."

8: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 8 (Senate1911.May8b.8)

Mr. MoCU:MBER (when his name was called). I am paired with the senior Senator from Mississippi [Mr. PERCY], but I understand he would vote the same way that I would upon this occasion, and therefore I shall vote. I vote " yea."

9: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 9 (Senate1911.May8b.9)

Mr. GALLINGER (when Mr. RooT's name was called). I was requested to announce that the Senator from New York [Mr. RooT] is paired with the Senator from Virginia [Mr. SWANSON].

10: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 10 (Senate1911.May8b.10)

· Mr. GALLINGER (when · Mr. STEPH E NSON'S name was called). I was requested to announce that the Senator from Wisconsin [Mr. STEPHENSON] is paired with the Senator from Alabama [Mr. BANKHEAD].

12: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 12 (Senate1911.May8b.12)

Mr. BR.A.NDEGEE. I was requested to announce that my colleague [Mr. McLEAN] is paired for the day with the junior Senator from Tennessee [Mr. LEA].

13: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 13 (Senate1911.May8b.13)

.Mr. GA.MBLE. My colleague [Mr. ORA WFORD] is ill, and for that reason is not in the Chamber at this time. If he were here, I know he would vote " yea."

14: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 14 (Senate1911.May8b.14)

The result was announced-yeas 66, nays 5, as follows:

16: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 16 (Senate1911.May8b.16)

Bacon Davis Lippitt Shively Bailey Dillingham Mccumber Simmons Borah Dixon Martin, Va. Smith, Md. Bradley du Pont Martine, N. J. Smith, Mich. Briggs other Myers Smoot Bristow Foster Nelson Stone Brown Gamble Nixon Sutherland Bryan Gore Oliver Taylor Burton Gronna Overman Thornton Chamberlain Guggenheim Owen Townsend Chilton Hitchcock Page Warren Clapp Johnson, Me. Paynter Watson Clark, Wyo. Johnston, Ala. Perkins Wetmore Crane Jones Poind e xter Williams Culberson Kenyon Pomerene Works Cullom Kern Rayner Curtis La Follette Reed

18: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 18 (Senate1911.May8b.18)

Brandegee Gallinger Heyburn Penrose Burnham

20: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 20 (Senate1911.May8b.20)

Bankh e ad Frye New lands Smith, S. C. Bourn e Lea O'Gorman Stephenson Clarke, Ark. Lodge Percy Swanson Crawford Lorimer Richardson Terrell Cummins McLean Root Tillman

21: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 21 (Senate1911.May8b.21)

So the motion was agreed to; and the Senate, as in Committee of the Whole, proceeded to consider t-he joint resolution.

22: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 22 (Senate1911.May8b.22)

Mr. BORAH. I understand there is a desire to move an adjo urnment at this time, perhaps until Thursday, owing to the fact that important hearings are being held before some 1 committees, and I shall gtre way for that motion, if it is the desire make it ·

23: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 23 (Senate1911.May8b.23)

Mr. CULLOM. I do not think it is the purpose that the Senate shall adjourn over until Thursday.

24: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 24 (Senate1911.May8b.24)

Mr. BORAH. Very well; I w a s in error to that extent.

25: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 25 (Senate1911.May8b.25)

Mr. CULLOM. I move that the Senate do now adjourn.

26: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 26 (Senate1911.May8b.26)

Mr. BAILEY. Will the Senator from Illinois withhold the motion until I can make a request?

28: Senate, May 8, 1911 (2), ¶ 28 (Senate1911.May8b.28)

The VICE PRESIDENT. The Senator from Illinois withholds the motion.

Connections graph

Enter all results↑ ↓ then Enter to open oneTry “Federalist 51”, “Article I, Section 8”, “Amendment 14”

Where you've been

    The places you have read, newest first, kept in this browser only. Nothing is sent anywhere.